peer-review

Quick Review

Exceptional peer review skill with comprehensive, systematic methodology covering all critical aspects of scientific manuscript evaluation. The description clearly conveys the skill's purpose for CLI invocation. Task knowledge is outstanding with detailed workflows, specific evaluation criteria, and actionable checklists across methodology, statistics, ethics, reproducibility, and reporting standards. Structure is excellent with logical stage-based organization and clear hierarchies, though the extensive detail in SKILL.md could potentially be modularized further. Novelty is strong: conducting rigorous multi-dimensional peer review requires substantial domain expertise and would consume many tokens for a CLI agent to perform ad-hoc; this skill meaningfully consolidates that knowledge. The specialized presentation review workflow (with mandatory image-based PDF inspection) demonstrates sophisticated handling of edge cases. Minor deductions for very dense SKILL.md that could delegate more detail to reference files, but overall this is a highly valuable, well-executed skill that significantly reduces the complexity and cost of systematic scientific review.