scouting-report-builder

Quick Review

The skill addresses a specialized domain (sports scouting) that could provide value, but the implementation is severely underdeveloped. The SKILL.md is essentially a generic template with placeholder text that hasn't been customized for scouting reports. Critical missing elements include: no concrete frameworks for analyzing players/teams, no specific metrics or criteria to evaluate (e.g., shooting efficiency, defensive positioning, play-calling tendencies), no sport-specific guidance, no data source integration methods, and no actual examples of scouting reports. The 'Common Use Cases' section contains only template placeholders without real trigger phrases or examples. For a CLI agent to successfully invoke this skill, it would need detailed rubrics for evaluating strengths/weaknesses, structured templates for different report types (pre-game, post-game, draft evaluation), and clear methodologies for film breakdown and matchup analysis. The structure is clean but only because there's minimal content. The novelty score reflects that comprehensive scouting report generation is genuinely complex and valuable, but the current implementation doesn't deliver on that promise.